Staffing and recruiting agency in Chicago, IL · Monday to Friday, 7 AM to 4 PM CT

Blog · For recruiters and hiring teams

The Real Price of Running Hiring In-House

One HR manager, three open roles and 600 applicants. A story about where the money goes, and the hours nobody counts.

A composite story based on published industry data · 8 minute read

An HR manager reviewing hiring plans with diverse colleagues

Maya is a composite character. The numbers around her are real.

Monday, 8:12 AM

Maya runs HR for a 90-person software company outside Chicago. That means payroll questions, benefits renewals, a policy handbook that needs updating, and, this quarter, three open roles: a DevOps engineer, a financial analyst and an operations manager.

By the time her coffee cools, the three job posts have pulled in more than 600 applications between them. Plenty of the resumes read almost identically. She opens the first one and starts reading.

The cost nobody budgets for

Ask most leadership teams what hiring costs and they’ll name the job board bill. The real number is bigger. SHRM’s 2025 benchmark puts the average cost of a single non-executive hire at $5,475, once advertising, agency fees, tools and internal time are counted. Maya has three to make.

Then there’s the department itself. Bloomberg BNA’s HR benchmarking found that companies with fewer than 250 employees spent about $2,966 per employee per year on the HR function in 2017, several times what the largest employers spent. For a company Maya’s size, that’s well over a quarter of a million dollars a year, and recruiting is only one of the jobs that budget has to cover.

Every hour Maya spends sorting resumes is an hour she isn’t spending on the people already on the payroll.

Week three: the phone-screen treadmill

Maya narrows the pile to 40 people worth a call. At 45 minutes a screen, including notes and scheduling, that’s 30 hours of her time. Half of the calls end within ten minutes, when it’s clear the candidate can’t do what the resume claimed.

Meanwhile the DevOps role is still empty. SHRM’s 2026 data puts the median time to fill a non-executive role at 39 days. Every one of those days, deployments wait, the engineering lead covers on-call shifts, and the roadmap slips a little further.

Quick math for one role

A $130,000 engineer is worth about $356 a day to the business. Thirty-nine days open is close to $14,000 of work not getting done, before counting the hiring cost itself. Try the calculator with your own numbers.

Week five: the hire that almost works

Maya makes an offer to the developer who interviewed best. Six weeks in, it’s clear he can talk about microservices far better than he can build them. Now she’s back to the start, with a team that’s more tired than before.

What changed

The next quarter, Maya tried something different. She handed the first round to Hire On Track. Every applicant completed Hire On Track’s AI-assisted assessment, a structured interview written for the role, and a Hire On Track recruiter reviewed the answers. Maya received a short list with skill-by-skill evidence, scores and transcripts.

She read four reports instead of 600 resumes. She held three interviews instead of 40 phone screens. And she got back to the work only she can do.

What to take from Maya’s story

  • Count the hidden costs: internal hours, open-seat days and mis-hires, not just job board fees.
  • The first-round phone screen is the most expensive filter you run. Replace it with evidence.
  • Scaling your hiring doesn’t have to mean scaling your HR headcount.

Sources

Give Your HR Team Its Week Back

Hand Hire On Track the first round and get a shortlist you can trust.

Get a vetted shortlist